Fault File Buy me a coffeeDonate
All models / All cars / Family & large SUVs / BMW X5 vs Porsche Cayenne

BMW X5 vs Porsche Cayenne

Both are large SUVs. First-time MOT failure at age 7, and what each one is known to fail on.

The Porsche Cayenne is the more reliable of the two. It fails its first MOT at age 7 12.9% of the time, against 13.9% for the BMW X5.

BMW X5
13.9%
fail at age 7
Rank 32 of 239 · 71k miles at 7 · 68,422 tests
Porsche Cayenne
12.9%
fail at age 7
Rank 26 of 239 · 65k miles at 7 · 25,007 tests

What each one fails on

Measured

The faults each records most at ages 6 to 9. Same figures as each full report.

BMW X5

A suspension pin, bush or joint excessively wornAdvisory7.6%
Fluid leaking excessively and likely to harm the environment or to pose a safety risk to other road usersAdvisory3.0%
A shock absorber damaged to the extent that it does not function or showing signs of severe leakageAdvisory1.5%
A suspension pin, bush or joint excessively wornFail1.1%
Engine MIL illuminated indicating a malfunctionFail0.8%
A brake hose ferrule excessively corrodedAdvisory0.7%

Porsche Cayenne

A suspension pin, bush or joint excessively wornAdvisory2.7%
A spring or spring component fractured or seriously weakenedFail2.6%
Fluid leaking excessively and likely to harm the environment or to pose a safety risk to other road usersAdvisory2.0%
Engine MIL illuminated indicating a malfunctionFail1.8%
A shock absorber damaged to the extent that it does not function or showing signs of severe leakageAdvisory1.2%
A headlamp or light source missing, inoperative or more than ½ not functioning in the case of LEDFail0.7%
Full BMW X5 report →Full Porsche Cayenne report →